Wednesday 11 July 2012

What to teach?


In today's story, we'll see some more witticisms from Mr Critical:
Carol was invited to an audition for a band that needed a female singer. She had met the guitarist of the band on facebook some weeks before, for he had seen her in a picture singing for an important choir. Well, actually, she wasn’t a singer but a medicine student who used to like singing and wanted to take her voice to a higher stage than her shower.
The guitarist of the band had previously sent a message to all the members letting them know the 4 songs that she had asked to be played for the audition; and, finally, the day arrived. But guess what? She came without rehearsing at all! ¬¬. She didn’t sing well any of the 4 songs she herself had asked for. “I think she’s too daring!” said the guitarist once Carol had gone out to be given a ride home by the bassist. “How can she dare to come to the audition without rehearsing!” he followed. -“Why did you invite her to come again to rehearsals?” asked the drummer. To which the guitarist replied: “Well, I, uh… I, er… I just thought she was kind of sensual, or perhaps she looked cute to me… and, er… I think we might need a bit of this image in the band, you know, to sell us better. What do you reckon?”
-“I reckon she’s not just daring, but dangerous! Just because of what you said, that she projects a cute, sort of sensual image. However, I agree with you that we might need a bit of it in our band” retorted the drummer. “But I feel a bit sad about the previous candidate, you know. She was too nervous. I think she’s very shy and for that reason she couldn't be picked, besides, she was not that good looking, although her voice wasn’t bad at all” he lamented.
This sometimes (or most of the times) happens in everyday life. Mr Critical asks to himself: What should teachers teach? It seems that being successful has somehow to do with being daring or a bit sensual (especially for women). Let’s take for example what happens at Mr Critical’s office. There, you can find some women working as English teachers, but they don’t even know how to write a formal letter in their own language, let alone in English. However, one of them is surprisingly the "second on board" -so to speak- of the Department, someone who the only word she knows in English is “ok, ok, ok” and "manash" (manage), "averash" (average), "mesash" (message), "reproved" (meaning 'failed'), and "she's a good cooker". But of course, she perfectly knows how to influence on people, on her boss, -the best brainwasher I've ever met, so his name should rather be 'Mr Power of Persuasion'- But this guy is evidently a simple wannabe 'eloquent' as he'll never persuade you, unless your IQ is really low. However, the "second on board" knows how to influence on him, and on her authorities, students, and even on certain colleagues. According to Mr Critical, teachers should teach how to be daring, astute, crafty, and cunning in order to be successful in life. It seems that intelligence, competence and professionalism based on speaking knowledgeably is regarded as secondary (or perhaps, unnecessary). What do you reckon?